from The Guardian
Shame on these sophisticated barbarians
go to article

What makes a 'world class' city?
go to article


from The New York Times
Rodin Show Visits Home of Artist’s Muses
go to article


from The Straits Times
Is the museum too 'Disney'?
go to article (PDF)

Just catching up on various museum-related news and behold the sheer coincidence of commentary. Starting with Jonathan Jones' criticism of the tendency of museums to be geared towards the gimmicky - or the "experiential" - at the expense of the "collection", such that exhibitions are often conceived to titillate (intellectually) instead of being engaging. This is reflected in the growing trend of (art) museums being built outside of Europe and North America, all trying to out-emulate each other, prompting Claire Hsu to wonder:
"How [...] is the 19th century European museum becoming a default model for modern art museums in certain parts of Asia?"
And two instances closer to home to pin down the point that museums cannot afford to be uncritical about the intellectual impact that it carries, willingly or otherwise. One, the story in the New York Times on a very bad case of colonial hang-over - although the one good thing to come out of this episode may be a badly needed infrastructure refurbishment at the National Museum in Phnom Penh. The other, a poignant plead to reconsider the "theme-park" make-over of our very own National Museum - and pointing back to Jone's article to close our circular reference.

1 comment:

  1. Ok, the debate of marketing musuem as a strategy of making world-class city is still boiling. If anyone is interested, i managed to dig out some old titles that are coherent with this Bilbao-effect debate:

    1. Gómez MV & González S (2001) "A Reply to Beatriz Plaza’s 'The
    Guggenheim-Bilbao Museum Effect'", International Journal of Urban & Regional Research, 25(4), p.898-900

    2. Plaza, B (1999) “The Guggenheim-Bilbao Museum Effect: A Reply to Gómez MV’s ‘Reflective Images: The Case of Urban Regeneration in Glasgow & Bilbao” in International Journal of Urban & Regional Research, 23(3), p.589-592

    3.Gómez MV (1998) "Reflective images: the case of urban regeneration in Glasgow & Bilbao, International Journal of Urban & Regional Research, 22(1), p.106-121

    in Gomez's article, she cautions her readers the long-term effects of Bilbao and the question of the defining "unique": "According to Matthew DeBord (2000), ‘there will be more Bilbaos — architecturally and financially . . . If Kren’s and the Guggenheim get what they want, New York will have a Gehry museum by 2007’. So there will be another Guggenheim museum designed by Frank Gehry, the same architect, with a very similar design which will also be made of titanium according to the model which was recently exhibited in Manhattan, as Beatriz Plaza herself admitted more recently (2000). So what exactly is unique?"

    Happy blogging and happy new year!

    ReplyDelete